Translate

Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Fake Priest Paul Crouch just flipped me the bird!

Paul Crouch Flips Off TBN Cameras in Jerusalem?

They say a picture is worth a thousand words. But, this picture of Paul Crouch of TBN only brings two words to mind. But, only focusing on the hand gesture and missing the bigger offense is really easy to do and is like missing the forest because of a tree. To make sure that you don't do that, ask yourself an important question regarding this photo:

What is MORE offensive, the hand gesture or the fact that Paul Crouch, a money grubbing charlatan con man who has made millions upon millions of dollars teaching rank heresy is wearing a clerical collar and broadcasting his flim flam from Jerusalem with the Temple Mount directly behind him? (the priest get-up must be his Halloween outfit since he's not a priest)
Paul_crouch_middle_finger-thumb-550x328

Online Source Warning. Online Source Is Not a Christian Site AND is Not safe for work!
Note: We've called TBN and they claim that the gesture was "unintentional".

To help you keep perspective on the Greater Offense we recommend that you read this news story entitled "Lavish spending of America's first family of televangelism revealed in bitter legal feud" -

Click Here to Read

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

UnMasking James MacDonald




Topics Covered by The Elephant's Debt 

Debt -
During the accumulation of this $65 million debt, did Pastor James MacDonald personally profit from the rapid expansion of his ministry?

Salary -
Which one of these well paid individuals is going to ask Pastor James MacDonald hard questions about his compensation, and are all the Elders aware of his compensation package?

Is this why Pastor James MacDonald stated that Jakes’ views on money, as opposed to his reformed brethren, are closer to the biblical view of money?

Who, at present, has the authority to determine the salary of James MacDonald? 


Power - 
With the battles for power behind him, the only problem yet to be tackled was the debt facing the church.  How could this be accomplished? 

5G Campaign - 
Is the pursuit of material wealth and the commitment to church growth principles limiting MacDonald’s ability to credibly critique the Prosperity Gospel movement and its leaders?

Elephant Room - 
Are we alone in our concerns about the debt, the salary and ER2?

The Void - 
If you wish to view and download all of the supporting documentation, please click here.

If you share our concerns and are presently wondering what to do next, please click here.

Everything is Documented - 
To learn more about what we hope may come of this, please click this link. 

The Hope - 
To learn more about who we are and why we wrote this website, please click here.

Our Story - 
Now that you know some of the reasons that we left Harvest, perhaps you would like to share a few concerns you have as well. 

     

    

 

if you know anyone led astray by Harvest Bible Chapel read this post!

Executive Summary


The Elephant’s Debt is a website dedicated to exploring some of the underlying reasons why many people have recently begun to both privately and publicly question the ministry of Pastor James MacDonald and Harvest Bible Chapel of Rolling Meadows, Illinois.

Over the first ten years of its active ministry, HBC could have been fairly categorized as a non-denominational, broadly evangelical church that was largely conservative in its biblical and fiscal orientation.   However, critical events in the early days of the new millennium appear to have brought about a significant shift in fiscal responsibility, which was later followed by an apparent shift in theological and methodological commitments.

By the close of 2010, Harvest’s balance sheet revealed that the church, while under the pastoral leadership of James MacDonald, had amassed approximately $65 million of debt.  While this number in and of itself is shocking, what makes it worse is that HBC leadership told the people in a letter that they were “not going to put our church in a bad position financially.”  Moreover, as will be demonstrated later, this debt load far exceeds what churches of similar size are known to carry.
Even more concerning is the fact that as of 2010, James MacDonald was making more than half a million dollars per year, not including any income potentially derived from sources outside of Harvest Bible Chapel and Walk in the Word. Finally, in the midst of Harvest accumulating these financial liabilities, James MacDonald purchased the $1.9 million Inverness estate formerly owned by U.S. Senator Peter Fitzgerald.  Additional details surrounding these issues will be addressed under “The Salary.”

In our opinion, weary of the consistent battles with the elder board over these financial issues, James MacDonald decided to reallocate the power within the church by redesigning the elder board and restructuring the governing constitution of Harvest Bible Chapel.  This reallocation of power shifted power away from the elders to himself.

Shortly thereafter, in the fall of 2011, James MacDonald and the recently expanded elder board of Harvest Bible Chapel rolled out the 5G Campaign, a new fundraising drive that publicly maintains prioritized goals of building out the worship center at the Niles campus and retrofitting the recently obtained Harvest Cathedral, before addressing “other projects … as funding allows.”  Curiously, the relief of the aforementioned debt was not listed as a top priority of the 5G Campaign by the leadership of Harvest Bible Chapel.  Thus, expansion of Pastor MacDonald’s influence appears to be of paramount importance, over and above the repeated admonition in Scripture to get free from debt.
As all of this was continuing to internally unfold at Harvest, plans for the Elephant Room 2 were being laid by James MacDonald.  As has been widely reported around the web, this event was problematic for two reasons. First, Bishop T.D. Jakes, a man who historically has been linked to Modalist theology, was asked very few questions on this controversial subject.  Secondly, and perhaps more significantly, nothing was said to Jakes in light of his associations with the Prosperity Gospel movement.  While this may not appear to be terribly significant, what must be noted is that James MacDonald had publicly stated prior to the event that he was “excited to hear [T.D. Jakes'] state his views on money, which may be closer to Scripture than the monasticism currently touring reformed world.”

For these reasons and many more, numerous families within the Harvest community have recently elected to worship elsewhere, while many of those that remain continue to seek answers from within.

For additional documentation and explanation, please feel free to either click on this link or to make use of the tabs provided above, beginning with “The Debt.”

Thursday, October 4, 2012

FREE STUFF!


If you remember I offered some free resources in honor of our 4000th blog view

Soooooo...... Margaret Gill, wife of beloved Calvary Baptist Elder - Doug Gill 
you just won your pick of 1 book and 1 CD series listed below 
(yes both, I am most generous like our Lord) 



CD series -

Baptism Debate MacArthur vs Sproul  (spoiler alert: Johnny Mac wins, he uses exegesis of Scripture instead of a combination of logic and reading into the passages)

Echoes from a Geneva Pulpit: The sermons of Calvin500 - Various Pastors, Historians and Theologians

God Alone - Sproul

The Holiness of God - Sproul ( the Sproul Classic)

5 things every Christian should know - Sproul



Books - 

Tortured For Christ - Wurmbrand

Reason to Believe - Sproul

Till we have faces - C S Lewis

Worship: the ultimate priority - MacArthur

The Soul's quest for God - Sproul



(I didn't have an actual photo of Margaret Gill so I used several other Margaret Gill photos from Google Images)




 


Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Justin Martyr


The Martyrdom of the Holy Martyrs Justin Martyr, Chariton, Charites, Paeon, and Liberianus

The text of this story of the martyrdom of Justin Martyr is taken from The Ante-Nicene Fathers, volume I. The grammar, wording, and some details of my perception of the prefect's attitude have been updated for ease of reading.
Chapter One:
Justin Martyr Is Examined by the Prefect Rusticus

Justin Martyr
Public domain image
ANCIENT INTRODUCTION: In the time of the lawless practicers of idolatry, wicked decrees were passed against the godly Christians in town and country. Rome was trying to force them to offer sacrifices to useless idols. Therefore, the holy men were arrested and brought before the prefect of Rome, Rusticus.
When they were brought before his judgment seat, the prefect Rusticus said to Justin, "Obey the gods at once, and submit to the kings."
"To obey the commandments of our Saviour Jesus Christ should bring neither blame nor condemnation," replied Justin.
Rusticus ignored the reply. "What kind of doctrines do you profess?"
Justin answered, "I have tried to learn all doctrines, but I have given in at last to the true doctrines: those of the Christians. I know they do not please you who hold false opinions." (see that Justin in no way tries friendship evangelism or ecumenicalism; he starts with you hold “false opinions” about doctrine) 
"But they please you, don't they, you completely wretched man?" the prefect sneered.
"Yes," Justin Martyr replied, "because I follow them with correct dogma." (again Justin cannot be confused with progressive emergent crowd not all ways are the right ways there is 1 sole correct Way and any other way is a false way that leads to death)
"So tell me, what is this proper dogma?"
"Correct dogma is found in the way we worship the God of the Christians," Justin Martyr began. "He has been one from the beginning, the maker and designer of the entire creation, visible and invisible. We also worship the Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, who was preached in advance by the prophets. They foretold that he was about to visit the human race as the herald of salvation and the teacher of good disciples."
Justin continued, "Nothing I say is significant compared with his limitless divinity. I acknowledge that only by prophetic power can he be sufficiently described, and the prophets did proclaim this One, whom I now say is the Son of God. I know that the prophets foretold his appearance among men from ancient times."
Rusticus seemed satisfied that this line of questioning had gone far enough, and he changed the subject.
Chapter Two:
Justin Martyr Is Questioned About Christian Meetings
"Where do you assemble?" Rusticus proceeded.
It's a beautiful thing to God when a Christian does battle with pain. When he faces threats, punishments and tortures by mocking death and treading underfoot the horror of the executioner; when he raises up his freedom in Christ as a standard before kings and princes; when he yields to God alone, and-triumphant and victorious-he tramples upon the very man who has pronounced the sentence upon him … God finds all these things beautiful.
–Minucius Felix, The Octavius 37)
"Wherever we want to and are able to," Justin replied. "Do you imagine that we all meet in the same place? Not so! The God of the Christians is not limited to a location. He is invisible, and he fills heaven and earth. Therefore, he is worshipped and glorified everywhere by the faithful." (its like I tell dispensationalists in Christianity there is no “holy land” all the Earth and universe are the Lord’s)
Rusticus sighed. This was no angry prefect. He was not the least bit interested in Justin's speech. "Just tell me where you personally assemble. In other words, in what place do you, Justin, gather your followers?"
"I live above a man named Martin, at the Timiotinian Bath." Justin paused, then, knowing what the next question would be, he continued, "During the entire time I've lived here, because I'm now living in Rome for the second time, I don't know about any other meetings. I've simply taught the truth to anyone willing to come to me."
Rusticus was ready to get down to business. "So are you a Christian or not?"
Justin replied, "Yes, I am a Christian."
Chapter Three:
Rusticus the Prefect Examines Justin Martyr's Companions
Rusticus glanced at the recorder, and the recorder nodded. With that the prefect was ready to move on to the others.
"And you, Chariton, are you also a Christian?"
Chariton replied, "I am a Christian by the command of God."
The prefect turned to the woman. "What say you, Charito?"
"I am a Christian by the grace of God," Charito replied.
He turned to Euelpistus. "And you? What are you?"
Euelpistus, who was a servant of Caesar, answered, "I, too, am a Christian. I have been freed by Christ, and by the grace of Christ I share in the same hope."
Rusticus made sure the recorder was getting all this, then asked Hierax, "And you? Are you a Christian?"
Hierax said, "Yes, I am a Christian, for I revere and worship the same God."
Marcus Aurelius would have been a general
at the time Justin was being martyred
Public domain image

Rusticus swept his eyes across the group in front of him. He had one more thing to clear up. It was appropriate to make some effort to save the lives of the accused. "Did Justin make you Christians?"
Hierax answered first, "I was a Christian, and I will remain a Christian."
Paeon, who had been asked nothing, chimed in, "I, too, am a Christian."
Rusticus looked at him. "And who taught you?"
"We received this good confession from our parents," Paeon replied.
Euelpistus had no intentions of letting Justin take the rap for all of them. "I listened to Justin willingly, but I learned to be a Christian from my parents as well."
"Where are your parents?" Rusticus asked.
"In Cappadocia."
"And yours?" He was asking Hierax.
"Christ is our true father, and faith in him is our mother. My earthly parents died, and I was driven out of Iconium in Phrygia. Then I came here."
There was one more to question. Rusticus the prefect asked Liberianus, "And what say you? Are you a Christian and unwilling to worship?"
Liberianus said, "I, too, am a Christian, for I worship and reverence the only true God."
There was one thing left to do. These Christian martyrs had to be given a chance to recant.
Chapter Four:
Rusticus Threatens Justin Martyr and the Other Christians
The prefect spoke to Justin Martyr first. "Listen, you who are called learned and think you know true doctrines. If you are scourged and beheaded, do you believe you'll ascend to heaven?"
"That is my hope," Justin replied. "If I endure these things, I shall have his gifts. I know that for all who have lived according to our teachings, the divine favor remains on them until the completion of the whole world."
Though death is decreed against those who teach or at all confess the name of Christ, we everywhere both embrace and teach it. And if you also read these words in a hostile spirit, you can do no more … than kill us; which indeed does no harm to us, but to you and all who unjustly hate us and do not repent, brings eternal punishment by fire.
–Justin Martyr, First Apology 45
"So you suppose that you will ascend into heaven to receive some payment for your faithfulness?"
"Not suppose, I know and am fully convinced of it," Justin Martyr replied.
Rusticus shrugged. "Let's get right to what matters, then. You've been brought here to offer sacrifice, all of you together, to the gods."
Justin wasn't interested. "No one in their right mind leaves godliness to take up ungodliness." (Again not an inkling of ecumenicalism, or universalism in Christianity)
"You're aware that unless you obey, you will be mercilessly punished?"
Justin answered, "Through prayer we can be saved because of our Lord Jesus Christ, even after we have been punished. This will become salvation and confidence to us at the much more fearful and universal judgment of our Lord and Savior."
The other martyrs echoed his sentiment. "Do whatever you want. We are Christians, and we don't sacrifice to idols."
Rusticus was uncaring. He had done his duty.
Chapter Five:
Rusticus Pronounces Sentence on Justin Martyr and His Companions
Rusticus stood to make his pronouncement. "Let those who have refused to sacrifice to the gods and to yield to the command of the emperor be scourged, then let them be led away and beheaded, according to the laws."
The holy martyrs, having glorified God, were taken to the customary place, beheaded, and they perfected their testimony in the confession of the Savior.
Some of the faithful secretly removed their bodies, then laid them in a suitable place. The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ worked with them, to whom be glory forever and ever. Amen.
My Comments
This Christian martyrs story is simple and straightforward, but it testifies to the faith of Justin Martyr and the Christians with him. It's one thing to say that you believe in Jesus Christ and the eternal life that he purchased with his blood; it is quite another to prove your faith by giving up your temporary life on this earth.
Not Likely To Be Martyred?
Since, o son, you desire martyrdom, hear. Be like Abel was, or like Isaac himself, or Stephen, who chose for himself on the way the righteous life. … First of all, overcome the evil one with your good deeds by living well. … Even now, if you have conquered by good deeds, you are [already] a martyr in him.
Instructions of Commodianus 62
It doesn't take special or unusual events to make a martyrdom glorious. There is no greater love, says the Scriptures, than to give up your life for a friend.
Having confessed Christ before men, martyrs like Justin Martyr, Chariton, Charito, Paeon, Hierax, and Liberianus will find that Jesus Christ will also confess them before the Father, who is God of all.
Let us be inspired to similar faith. There are places where men, women, and children continue to give their earthly lives in hope of the eternal life promised by God, who cannot lie, since before the world began.
Even here in the West, however, where martyrdom is unlikely, we have daily opportunities to deny our fears and embarrassment and to stand up as disciples of the Lord Jesus Christ, confessing him before men in return for that final and great confession to be made by Jesus Christ before his Father and ours.

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

James


The Death of James the Just, Brother of Jesus Christ

This is the earliest known testimony to the death of James the Just, brother of Jesus our Lord.

What a strange character James is! There is no indication that he followed Jesus at all during Jesus' earthly lifetime. After the resurrection, however, he is one of the leading figures in the church.
I suppose this makes sense. After all, it would be hard for any of us to be convinced that our big brother is the creator of the world. On the other hand, if he rose from the dead it might spark a change in us!
However, James is odd in other respects. Unlike the twelve, he never left Jerusalem. History says he was appointed as overseer there by the apostles. Acts, though, leaves us with the impression that he carried as much or more authority than the apostles who appointed him! (As the ruler of the 1st century Jerusalem Church)
Not only did he not leave Jerusalem, but surely he was the most Jewish of the apostles. (James is called an apostle in Scripture—e.g., Gal. 1:19—but he was not one of the twelve.) While he acknowledged that the Gentiles did not need to keep the Law, he was always the one most on the side of the Law. Peter refused to eat with Gentiles out of fear of James (Gal. 2:11-12), and James asked Paul to buy the sacrifices for men about to take a Nazirite vow (and Paul complied – Acts 21:18-26!!!).
James remained the leader of the Jerusalem church until his death around A.D. 62. This is the account of his martyrdom according to Hegesippus (a 2nd century Christian about whom little is known), which is quoted in Eusebius' Ecclesiastical History, vol. II, ch. 23 (A.D. 323).
I'm retelling the story in my own words, not quoting him. Eusebius gives three versions of the death of James: one from Clement of Alexandria, one from Hegesippus, and one from Josephus (yes, Josephus' Antiquities was being quoted way back then!). This is Hegesippus' version, which Eusebius judges the most accurate.
Historians, however, prefer Josephus' account of the death of James, which I'll cover in a paragraph or two at the end of the page.
Introduction: What Sort of Person James Was
James was called "the Just" because of his great righteousness. Rumor has it that he was a Nazirite from his mother's womb. He didn't drink any wine or liquor, and he didn't eat meat. He never cut his hair, did not anoint himself with oil, and did not bathe.
Note: I don't believe this rumor. Somehow I can't picture Joseph and Mary requiring this of Jesus' younger brother, nor can I picture a long-haired guy who never bathed as the long term bishop of Jerusalem, known to posterity as "James the Just."
He was the only one allowed to enter the temple alone, and he prayed and asked forgiveness for the Jews so much that his knees became hard like a camel's. As well as "the Just," he was known as "Bulwark of the people."




Seven Sects of Judaism
These sects are mentioned by Hegesippus, a little-known Christian of the 2nd century. Others refer to "the seven sects," but the list is not always the same. Here are Hegesippus' sects:
1.    Essenes
2.    Galileans
3.    Hemerobaptists
4.    Masbotheans
5.    Samaritans
6.    Sadducees
7.    Pharisees
James was so righteous, in fact, that he was respected by all the seven sects of Judaism (see sidebar). They used to ask him his opinion of Jesus, to which he would reply that Jesus was the Savior. Since some of those sects didn't believe in a resurrection, few among them believed in Jesus as their Christ.
Those who did, however, believed because of James.
James the Just Arouses the Wrath of the Rulers
After a while, James' influence became so strong that even some of the rulers believed, which horrified the scribes and Pharisees. They became afraid that soon the people would be flocking to Jesus as the Christ.
Somehow, perhaps because of his strict observance of the Law, the Pharisees thought they could get James to discourage the people from believing. They asked him to stand at the pinnacle of the temple on Passover and speak.
Apparently, James agreed.
They brought him to the top of the temple, and they shouted to him from below:
"Oh, righteous one, in whom we are able to place great confidence; the people are led astray after Jesus, the crucified one. So declare to us, what is this way, Jesus?"
Obviously, this wasn't a very wise thing for them to do. James was ready to take full advantage of such a wonderful opportunity as this!
His words are memorable:
Why do you ask me about Jesus, the Son of Man? He sits in heaven at the right hand of the great Power, and he will soon come on the clouds of heaven!
The Pharisees were horrified, but the people were not. The began shouting, "Hosanna to the Son of David!"
The Pharisees, realizing the awful mistake they'd made, began crying out, "Oh! Oh! The righteous one is also in error!"
The Death of James the Just
You can probably guess that this had little effect on the crowd. So the next obvious thing to do was to push him down from the temple, letting the people know exactly what happens to those who dare to believe in Jesus.
They climbed the temple as the people shouted, reached the top, and threw James from the pinnacle of the temple.
It didn't kill him.
He rose to his knees and began to pray for them. "I beg of you, Lord God our Father, forgive them! They do not know what they are doing."
This would not do! The Pharisees on the ground began to stone him as he prayed, while those from the roof rushed down to join the execution.
One of the priests, however, a son of the Rechabites mentioned by Jeremiah the prophet (ch. 35), shouted, "Stop! What are you doing! The righteous one is praying for you."
It was too late. A fuller (i.e., launderer) took out one of the clubs that he used to beat clothes and smashed James on the head, killing him with one blow.
Ramifications of the Death of James the Just
According to Hegesippus, Vespasian invaded Israel and besieged Jerusalem immediately after the Pharisees murdered James. The events were so closely related in time, he says, that "the more sensible even of the Jews were of the opinion that [the death of James] was the cause of the siege of Jerusalem."
The problem with that idea is that the siege of Jerusalem happened in A.D. 66, and Josephus says that the death of James happened after Porcius Festus had died and before Albinus became procurator of Judea. While I don't know the history of Roman governors well enough for that to mean anything to me, historians tell us that means James the Lord's brother died in A.D. 62.
I may not have the Roman governors of Judea memorized, but I can do that math. That's a four year gap.
That is probably too long for Hegesippus' "immediately" statement to be true, but the events may still be related. Even Josephus testifies that the illegal murder of James offended the Jews so much that they met Albinus on his way to Jerusalem to get help on the matter. If the death of James stirred up Jerusalem that much, it could easily have had something to do with the First Jewish-Roman War just four years later.
Josephus' Account of the Death of James the Just
According to Josephus, Ananus became the high priest of Jerusalem after the procurator, Porcius Festus, died. While the new procurator, Albinus, was on the way, Ananus saw the opportunity to get rid of James.
Josephus does not say why Ananus wanted the death of James other than that he "was of an exceeding bold and reckless disposition."
Josephus makes it very simple. Ananus gathered the Sanhedrin, accused James of violating the Law along with some others and had them all stoned. As a consequence, Albinus removed Ananus from his position of high priest upon his arrival.

Monday, October 1, 2012

Lessons from Church History # 1

Quotes About Abortion

Quotes about abortion from throughout Christian History.

Letter to Diognetus, A.D. 80 - 160

[Christians] marry, as do all. They beget children, but they do not destroy their offspring. (ch. 5)

Letter of Barnabas, A.D. 80 - 130

You shall not slay a child by procuring an abortion, nor shall you destroy it after it is born. (ch. 19)
[In the way of darkness] are people ... who are murderers of children and destroyers of the workmanship of God. (ch. 21)

Justin Martyr, c. A.D. 155

We have been taught that to expose newborn children [i.e., to leave them out to die or be found] is what wicked men do. We have been taught this so that we will not do harm to anyone and so that we will not sin against God. First because we see that almost all so exposed are raised as prostitutes[both boys and girls, according to Ante-Nicene Fathers note].
     Second, [we fear] that same may not be picked up, but die, and we will be murderers. (First Apology 27, 29)

Athenagoras, A.D. 177

When we say that those women who use drugs to bring on abortion commit murder and will have to give an account to God for the abortion, on what principle should we commit murder? For the same person would not regard the very fetus in the womb as a created being, and therefore an object of God’s care, and then, when it has passed into life, kill it. Nor would the same person avoid exposing an infant, because those who expose them are chargeable with child-murder, then, on the other hand, when it has been reared, destroy it.(A Plea for the Christians 35)

Tertullian, c. A.D. 210

For us, since we have forbidden murder once and for all, we may not even destroy the fetus in the womb, even though at that point the human being still dervies its blood from other parts of the body for sustenance.
     To hinder a birth is merely a speedier killing of a man. Nor does it matter whether you take a way a life that is born or destroy one that is preparing to be born. It is a human if it is going to be a human. You already have the fruit in its seed. (Apology 9)